Fall Special:$50 off for new customers$50 off
Pest control onLong Island
Pestify Pest Control
Call 631-681-5581Same-day and next-day visitsor request a free quote
A Pestify technician holding an opossum, wildlife control in Oyster Bay, NY
  • 5.0 Google
  • 4.9 Thumbtack
  • 5.0 Angi
  • 5.0 Facebook

Wildlife Control in Oyster Bay, NY

Do you need wildlife control in Oyster Bay? We can help with deer in gardens in Upper Brookville, raccoons under decks near the harbor and bats in old houses near Raynham Hall. Our licensed wildlife division covers the 11771 ZIP code.

  • NYS Wildlife Control License
  • Humane trapping and removal
  • 1-year warranty on sealed entry points
  • New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
  • NWCOA
  • NWCOA EPIC certification
  • Thumbtack 2025 Top Pro
  • Safe for pets and kids
  • Fully insured in NYS

Wildlife Control Services We Offer in Oyster Bay, NY

Licensed, humane wildlife control in Oyster Bay and the towns around it.

A Pestify wildlife trap set on a roof, wildlife control in Oyster Bay, NY
Every removal ends with the entry point sealed, so nothing else follows it in.

Why Oyster Bay Homeowners Call Pestify for Wildlife

  • Same-day and next-day serviceOyster Bay is about 31 miles west of our Port Jefferson Station office. We take Nesconset Highway to Route 25A, then follow 25A west through Huntington and Cold Spring Harbor.
  • Humane removal and sealingBats in an old attic near Raynham Hall get a one-way exit, never a trap. Raccoons along the harbor are trapped humanely. Then we seal the chimney gap, vent or soffit with heavy screening or metal.
  • Free inspection, price firstThe wildlife inspection is free for Oyster Bay homes, from the roofline to the space under the deck. On older houses downtown, we check the chimney flashing and the gaps where old trim meets the roof. You get the price before any work starts.
  • Licensed wildlife divisionOwner Rob Cenatiempo leads our wildlife division and holds the New York State Wildlife Control License. His team covers Oyster Bay from the downtown streets to the wooded lots of Cove Neck and Upper Brookville.

What Wildlife Customers Near Oyster Bay Say

People like us. Pests don’t. What homeowners across Nassau County say about Pestify.

Carol FulkersonGoogle review

Employees are extremely cordial and very friendly and do a good job.

Dorit PintoGoogle review

Highly recommended!!! Best service always on time. Professionals!!!

BlakeGoogle review

Pestify is a great local family owned and operated company. They have very good communication and work well around your schedule

Freddy GomezGoogle review

Lucas was great and very knowledgeable regarding the whole process.

Lynne ManciniGoogle review

Excellent communication and nick is great to work with. Crew is respectful.

Ralph CohanGoogle review

Your tech Lucas was on time, notified us prior to his arrival, explained his approach to our issues and explained the process of the quarterly work to be expected over the next year. We are very happy with all we have seen thus far.

Swipe for more reviews

Our Wildlife Control Process in Oyster Bay

What happens from the first call to the sealed entry point in Oyster Bay.

  1. Call usCall and tell us what you notice: scratching in the chimney, a raccoon on the deck or shrubs chewed in Upper Brookville. Each sign points to a different animal. Our wildlife team comes west along Route 25A.
  2. Inspection and priceA licensed technician inspects the roofline, attic, chimney and deck for the way in. On old houses near West Main Street, that often means gaps in the trim and chimney flashing. The inspection is free, and you get the price first.
  3. Humane removal and sealingWe trap raccoons, squirrels and opossums humanely over a 10-day trapping period and give bats a one-way exit. Then we close the opening with heavy screening or metal, backed by a 1-year warranty. For deer in Upper Brookville and Oyster Bay Cove, we use repellents, fencing and other barriers.

Our Oyster Bay Wildlife Team

Oyster Bay is on our Nassau County wildlife routes, about 31 miles from our office in Port Jefferson Station. A visit here might be bats in an old house downtown or deer in a garden on a wooded lot above the harbor.

Nick Moran, owner and CEO of Pestify
Nick MoranOwner, CEO
Rob Cenatiempo, owner and COO of Pestify
Rob CenatiempoOwner, COO
Richie Lacalandra, field supervisor at Pestify
Richie LacalandraField supervisor
Karl Lacalandra, pest control supervisor at Pestify
Karl LacalandraPest control supervisor

The crew at your door

Screened, trained in-house and paired with a senior tech. Same familiar faces every visit.

Meet the whole team
  • Pestify technician in uniform
  • Pestify technician in uniform
  • Pestify technician in uniform
  • Pestify technician in uniform
  • Pestify technician in uniform
  • Pestify technician in uniform

Wildlife Control Across Oyster Bay and Nassau County

Our wildlife technicians cover the Oyster Bay hamlet and the 11771 ZIP code. That includes Cove Neck, Oyster Bay Cove, Upper Brookville and the parts of Mill Neck the Oyster Bay post office serves.

Wooded lots in Upper Brookville and Oyster Bay Cove see deer browsing shrubs and gardens. Homes along the harbor and near Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park see raccoons under decks and birds nesting in vents. Downtown, old chimneys and attics near West Main Street draw bats and squirrels.

Deer are spreading west across Nassau’s North Shore, and they have been seen around Oyster Bay. The harbor shore, the Mill Neck Creek marshes and wooded lots give raccoons and opossums cover. Old houses downtown have chimneys and attic gaps that bats and squirrels use.

Map of Long Island with pins on the Suffolk County and Nassau County towns Pestify serves
© Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

ZIP codes we serve

  • 11771

Locations near Oyster Bay we serve

Get a Free Wildlife Control Quote in Oyster Bay

Free inspection and estimate in Oyster Bay. Your price before any trapping or sealing.

  • Same-day serviceVisits across Oyster Bay and Nassau County.
  • Humane removalLicensed by New York State. Entry points sealed.
  • Free inspectionNo obligation, no pressure.

Rather talk? Call (631) 681-5581

Answers to Oyster Bay Wildlife Control Questions

Anything else? The phone is faster.

631-681-5581
How fast can you get to Oyster Bay for wildlife control?

We offer same-day and next-day service in Oyster Bay and across Nassau County. Call (631) 681-5581 and we’ll give you the first open time.

Are there really deer in Oyster Bay now?

Yes. Deer have moved west into Nassau’s North Shore and have been seen around Oyster Bay. Officials link them to car crashes, ticks and damaged plantings. We don’t trap deer. We set up repellents, fencing or other barriers where they enter.

Raccoons keep getting under my deck near the harbor. What can you do?

The harbor shore and the Mill Neck Creek marshes give raccoons food and cover close to homes. We trap the raccoon humanely. Then we close the gap under the deck with buried screening, so the next one can’t dig in.

Do you cover Cove Neck and Upper Brookville?

Yes. Parts of both villages use the Oyster Bay post office and the 11771 ZIP code, and they are part of our Oyster Bay coverage. Their wooded lots see deer, raccoons and squirrels. The inspection is free, and you get the price first.

How much does wildlife control cost in Oyster Bay?

It depends on the animal, how it got in and how many openings need sealing. The inspection and estimate are free, and you get the price before any trapping or exclusion starts.

How long does trapping take?

Trapping for raccoons, squirrels, groundhogs and opossums runs over a 10-day period. Animals don’t always walk into a trap on schedule, so no one can promise a capture. If more time is needed, we only extend with your OK.

Do you guarantee the sealing work?

Yes. The entry points we repair and seal carry a 1-year warranty. If one of those seals fails within the year, we fix it at no charge.

What wildlife is most common in Oyster Bay?

Deer are spreading west across Nassau’s North Shore, and they have been seen around Oyster Bay. The harbor shore, the Mill Neck Creek marshes and wooded lots give raccoons and opossums cover. Old houses downtown have chimneys and attic gaps that bats and squirrels use.

Are you licensed for wildlife control?

Yes. Our wildlife division holds the New York State Wildlife Control License, and every removal is humane.